VA LOANS · SAN DIEGO COUNTY
Real VA appraisal disputes, including Tidewater, reconsiderations of value, and the termite clearance rule, explained by a San Diego mortgage broker who once got a VA appraisal corrected by $700,000.
By Adam Cato, Mortgage Broker | NMLS #1855852 | Updated October 2026
What You Will Learn
Quick Answer
Most VA appraisal issues fall into two categories: the property doesn’t meet VA Minimum Property Requirements, which has to be resolved in escrow before closing, or the appraised value comes in below the contract price. When a low value is expected, the file goes through Tidewater, which gives the buyer’s agent a chance to submit comparable sales before the appraisal is finalized. If the value still comes in low, a formal reconsideration of value can be submitted using comps and VA guideline errors the original appraiser missed; in one case this correction added $700,000 to a valuation. Sellers accepting a VA offer should also know they’re typically agreeing to Section 1 termite clearance, which can get expensive once they’re under contract.
Sources: U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs; Adam Cato client files (anonymized).
Most VA deals close without drama. When one doesn’t, it’s almost always the appraisal, either the property doesn’t meet VA requirements, or the value comes in under the contract price. Here’s what each situation actually looks like, including a reconsideration of value that moved a valuation by $700,000, and what sellers should know before accepting a VA offer.
When the Property Doesn’t Meet Minimum Property Requirements
The VA wants the home to be safe, sound, and sanitary. If it falls short, the appraiser issues the appraisal “subject to,” meaning specific items have to be addressed and resolved in escrow before the loan can close. (See the full Minimum Property Requirements checklist in The VA Loan Process.)
Tidewater: When the Value Is Expected to Come in Low
When an appraiser believes the value is going to come in under the contract price, the file becomes subject to Tidewater. The buyer’s agent gets alerted and can submit comparable sales for properties like the subject property, giving the appraiser a chance to reconsider before the report is finalized.
Earlier this year I had a property in El Cajon go through this. The agent and I pulled comps that matched the home more closely, and once the appraisal report came back, we could see the appraiser had used comparables that weren’t really like the subject property. We found better comps and requested a reconsideration of value, which brought the appraised value from $685,000 to $715,000, a $30,000 increase.
It still came in below the contract price, but the sellers were willing to come down to meet it. The buyers got the home at a lower price, put 0% down, and ended up with a noticeably lower monthly payment than they’d originally budgeted for.
A $700,000 Reconsideration of Value
This is the hardest VA file I’ve worked. A borrower wanted to pull over $2 million in cash out of his triplex in San Diego. The appraisal came back $700,000 below where it needed to be for the refinance to work.
Going through the appraisal report, I found a couple of issues that didn’t line up with VA guidelines:
- The appraiser didn’t use an income valuation approach, only sales comparison, and there were no comps nearby to support it
- He never expanded the search outside the zip code, where comparable properties were available and would have supported a higher value
It took several weeks. I put together the comparables the appraiser hadn’t accounted for and documented the specifics of the property. Following VA guidelines, the reconsideration of value was escalated to one of the VA’s highest valuation authorities.
| Stage | Appraised Value |
|---|---|
| Original VA appraisal | About $1.7 million, roughly $700,000 short of what the refinance needed |
| After reconsideration of value | Over $2.4 million |
That $2.4 million figure was exactly where the borrower believed the valuation should have been from the start. He ended up with a very successful refinance.
What Catches Sellers Off Guard on a VA Offer
When a seller accepts a VA offer and agrees to Section 1 termite clearance on the buyer’s behalf, they can end up writing a blank check to a termite company. Termite companies know the homeowner is in escrow and under a deadline, and they tend to charge more because the seller doesn’t have much room to push back on the recommended repairs.
The best thing a seller can do is have the home inspected for termites before putting it on the market, so there are no surprises once an offer is already on the table.
VA Appraisal FAQs
What is Tidewater on a VA loan?
Tidewater is the process where the buyer’s agent is alerted that a VA appraisal is expected to come in under value, so they can submit comparable sales to dispute it before the appraisal is finalized.
What is a reconsideration of value?
It’s a formal request to review an appraised value, backed by comparables the appraiser didn’t account for or by errors against VA guidelines. In one case, it moved the value up by $700,000.
What does “appraisal subject to” mean?
The property has issues that don’t meet Minimum Property Requirements, and those items have to be resolved in escrow before closing.
Why should sellers get a termite inspection before listing?
On a VA deal, the seller is typically agreeing to Section 1 clearance. Finding issues before you’re in escrow means you aren’t negotiating repairs under a deadline.

Adam Cato
Mortgage Broker · Certified Veterans Loan Specialist · NMLS #1855852 · Anchor Funding, Inc.
Adam Cato is a San Diego mortgage broker with Anchor Funding, Inc. and a Certified Veterans Loan Specialist, a designation from the National Association of Mortgage Brokers (NAMB). He helps buyers in California, Arizona and Texas compare loan options and get pre-approved. He’s personally taken VA appraisal disputes, including reconsiderations of value, through escalation with the VA to get his clients the valuation they deserve.